Description

Section 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), 1908, deals with the penalty imposed on a party for failing to comply with the orders of the court. This section is primarily concerned with situations where a party to a suit fails to comply with the directions given by the court in the course of proceedings. The section emphasizes accountability and discourages non-compliance with procedural requirements, ensuring that the process of civil litigation is conducted efficiently and justly.

---

Key Features of Section 32 - Penalty for Default

1. Default in Appearance or Non-Compliance:

   • Section 32 imposes a penalty on the party who fails to comply with an order or direction issued by the court. This non-compliance can be in relation to various aspects of the suit, such as:
     • Failure to attend hearings or appear in court when required.
     • Failure to pay costs as directed by the court.
     • Non-compliance with orders for the production of documents or evidence.
     • Failing to adhere to court deadlines for submitting documents or filings.

2. Imposition of Penalty:

   • If a party fails to comply with the court’s order, the court has the discretion to impose a penalty on the defaulting party. The penalty may include, but is not limited to:
     • Costs of the suit, including the opposing party's costs, if the non-compliance causes delays or inconvenience.
     • Disallowance of claims or evidence that the party was supposed to produce.
     • Adverse inference may be drawn against the defaulting party, which could weaken their case.
     • The party’s action or defense may be struck out or dismissed by the court if the defaulting party’s behavior is egregious or if the default is persistent.

3. Court’s Discretion to Decide Penalty:

   • The penalty imposed under Section 32 is at the discretion of the court. The court will assess the circumstances surrounding the default before deciding on the appropriate penalty. Factors that the court may consider include:
     • The nature of the default (whether it was intentional or due to negligence).
     • The severity of the default and its impact on the overall case.
     • The previous conduct of the party during the litigation process.
     • Whether the default was deliberate or if there were genuine reasons for not complying.

4. Penalties for Defaulting Parties:

   • If a plaintiff defaults, the court may:
     • Dismiss the suit, particularly if the plaintiff fails to take necessary steps or comply with court procedures.
     • If the default is minor, the court may order the plaintiff to pay the costs of the other party due to the delay caused.
   • If a defendant defaults, the court may:
     • Proceed to hear the suit ex parte, meaning the court will continue the proceedings and may even pass a judgment in favor of the plaintiff, assuming no valid defense is offered by the defendant.
     • The defendant may be penalized with the payment of costs for the delay caused by their failure to appear or comply with the court's directions.

5. Types of Default and Consequences:

   • Failure to Appear:
     • If a party fails to appear for hearings or hearings are delayed due to their absence, the court may impose penalties such as costs, or in some cases, the case may proceed without the absent party’s input.
   • Failure to Provide Documents/Evidence:
     • If a party does not comply with the court's order to submit evidence or documents, the court may decide not to consider such evidence, which could adversely affect the party’s position in the case.
   • Failure to Pay Costs:
     • If the party defaults in paying the costs imposed by the court, the penalty can include the dismissal of the case or a fine for non-payment.

6. Discretionary Nature of Penalty:

   • The penalty for default is not mandatory in all cases; the court will determine the most appropriate course of action based on the facts and circumstances. Section 32 leaves the penalty to the discretion of the court, allowing it to be flexible depending on the situation.

7. Exercising Judicial Discretion:

   • In cases where a party is not complying with the court's order, the court may give the defaulting party a chance to explain the delay or failure. The court may provide some leniency in cases where the failure was unintentional or due to extenuating circumstances.
   • If the default is found to be wilful and deliberate, the court is likely to impose a stricter penalty to enforce compliance with the rules of civil procedure.

Punishment

Non-Appearance in Court:

• A party’s failure to appear in court when required can lead to the dismissal of the case if the party is the plaintiff, or the suit can be heard ex parte if the defaulting party is the defendant. This could have serious consequences on the party's case.
• If there are repeated non-appearances, the party may face additional monetary penalties or may even be ordered to pay the opposing party's legal costs incurred due to the delays.

Failure to Produce Documents or Evidence:

• A party who fails to comply with the court's order to produce documents or evidence may have their evidence disregarded. The court may also impose a penalty or fine for the failure to cooperate.
• In extreme cases, the court may strike out the party's case or defense for failure to comply with the court’s procedural orders.

Failure to Pay Costs:

• If a party fails to pay costs as directed by the court, the court may take adverse actions against the defaulting party. This could include striking out their claim or defense, imposing further fines, or dismissing the case altogether.

Adverse Inference:

• In cases of wilful default, the court can draw adverse inferences against the party in default. This could mean that the party will suffer an unfavorable outcome due to their failure to comply with court orders, making it more difficult for them to win the case.