Description

Section 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), 1908, addresses the judgment and decree of a civil court in India. The section provides guidance on when and how the court is required to pronounce a judgment and make a decree at the conclusion of a civil suit. A judgment is the reasoned decision given by the court, while a decree is the formal order passed by the court directing that certain actions be taken.

---

Key Features of Section 33 - Judgment and Decree

1. Time Frame for Pronouncing Judgment:

   • Section 33 mandates that a judgment should be pronounced in open court and in writing. The judgment should be delivered after the court has heard all arguments and considered the evidence presented by the parties.
   • Time Limit for Pronouncing Judgment:
     • The judgment must be pronounced as soon as possible after the arguments have concluded. The court is expected to make its decision on the matter promptly, ensuring that justice is not unduly delayed.
     • In cases where the judgment is not pronounced immediately, the court should give a date for the pronouncement of the judgment and inform all parties involved.

2. Pronouncement of Decree:

   • A decree is a formal order passed by the court in favor of one of the parties, based on the judgment. The decree follows the judgment and is the final expression of the court’s decision.
   • A decree can be either:
     • Preliminary Decree: A decree that determines certain aspects of the case but does not dispose of the entire suit.
     • Final Decree: A decree that finally disposes of the case and resolves all issues.
   • The court's decree must align with the judgment, and it directs the enforcement of the court's decision.

3. Content of the Judgment:

   • The judgment should be written and should clearly indicate:
     • The issues raised in the case.
     • The evidence considered.
     • The reasons for the court's decision.
   • The judgment should also specify the relief granted to the winning party (such as damages, injunction, etc.) and the corresponding decree that is passed.

4. Form of Decree:

   • The decree should be drawn up in a specific format and must be signed by the presiding judge. It reflects the court’s decision and provides instructions on how the judgment is to be carried out. This could include the payment of money, the performance of specific actions, or an injunction to prevent certain actions.
   • A decree must specify whether it is preliminary or final, and it must set out the terms of the judgment.

5. Execution of Decree:

   • A decree cannot be executed until it is formally drawn up and signed by the judge. After that, the winning party can request the court to enforce the decree through execution proceedings.
   • Execution proceedings involve the legal process by which the court's decree is enforced. If a party does not comply voluntarily, the court may issue orders like attachment of property, arrest, or other coercive measures to ensure the execution of the decree.

6. Effect of Judgment and Decree:

   • The judgment gives the reasons for the court's decision, while the decree provides a formal order or direction to carry out the judgment.
   • A decree is legally binding, and its non-compliance could lead to the court taking coercive action to ensure compliance.
   • Once a decree is passed, it is enforceable in the same manner as a court judgment. The person who receives the decree can request its execution through court proceedings.

7. Appeal and Review:

   • A party who is dissatisfied with the judgment or decree has the right to appeal to a higher court. However, if the appeal does not stay the execution of the decree, the decree will continue to be enforced.
   • In certain cases, the review of a judgment may be sought, but this is only allowed on specific grounds, such as the discovery of new evidence or a grave error of law or fact.

8. Consolidated Nature of the Judgment and Decree:

   • The judgment is the basis for the decree, and the two must align. A judgment gives the rationale for the decree, and a decree is the formal expression of that decision.
   • Section 33 highlights that the judgment and decree together provide closure to the civil suit and create the foundation for the implementation of the court’s decision.

9. Refusal to Pass Judgment or Decree:

   • If a judge delays the pronouncement of a judgment or decree, the parties may file a complaint, and the higher courts may intervene to ensure compliance with the law. The delay in passing the judgment or decree may result in the party affected by the delay seeking judicial remedies for the delay.

Punishment

1. Failure to Pronounce Judgment or Decree:

   • If a judge fails to pronounce the judgment or decree within a reasonable time, they may be subjected to disciplinary action. The high court has the authority to discipline judges who violate the time frame for delivering judgments.
   • Delays in delivering judgment may also be a ground for an appeal, and the higher courts may intervene if a party is unduly prejudiced by a delay.

2. Contempt of Court:

   • If a party refuses to comply with the court’s decree, they can be charged with contempt of court. This could result in penalties such as:
     • Fines.
     • Imprisonment.
   • Failure to comply with the decree can be interpreted as a disruption of justice, and the court has the power to enforce the decree through coercive measures like attachment of property or arrest.

3. Execution of Decree:

   • If the decree is not executed voluntarily by the losing party, the court can take enforcement measures such as attachment of assets, freezing of bank accounts, or the issuance of arrest warrants.

4. Failure to Obey Court’s Order:

   • If a party fails to obey an order passed as part of the judgment or decree, they can face serious consequences like fines, costs, or imprisonment.

5. Appeal Against Decree:

   • If a party is dissatisfied with the decree, they may appeal to a higher court. However, the appeal does not automatically stay the decree unless the appellate court specifically grants a stay order.