Description

Section 64 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), 1908 addresses the transfer of property after it has been attached by a court in the course of executing a decree. It stipulates that any private alienation (i.e., transfer or sale) of property that has been attached during execution proceedings is void unless the court gives explicit permission.

---

1. Overview of the Section

• Section 64 is designed to protect the interests of creditors during the execution process by preventing a debtor from transferring or selling attached property to avoid liability.
• When a debtor's property is attached by the court, it becomes part of the legal process to satisfy the claims of the creditor. Attachment essentially gives the creditor a legal claim over the property to recover the owed debt.

2. Prohibition of Private Alienation

• After property is attached, the debtor cannot sell, transfer, or alienate that property in any way without the court's permission. This is to ensure that the creditor can secure the property to satisfy the judgment against the debtor.
• Any sale or transfer of property by the debtor after attachment is deemed invalid. This means that if the debtor tries to sell or transfer the property to a third party, such actions will have no legal effect. The court retains control over the property.

3. Legal Impact of Alienation

• Private alienation of attached property is automatically void if the debtor transfers the property to someone else during the execution process.
• The purchaser of the property in such a transaction is also at risk. If they are unaware of the attachment and proceed with the purchase, they would be acquiring the property subject to the attachment, which means that the court can still execute the property for the debt.

4. Exception – Court’s Permission

• If the debtor seeks to sell or transfer the attached property, they must apply to the court for permission. If the court deems it appropriate, it may allow the transfer or sale of the property, provided that the creditor’s interest is protected and the sale does not interfere with the execution process.
• The court may allow the debtor to sell the property if it’s necessary for the debtor’s livelihood, or the sale is for some other justified purpose.

5. Purpose of the Section

• The section seeks to protect the interests of the creditor by ensuring that once property is attached, it cannot be removed from the reach of the court's execution process.
• It also prevents the debtor from engaging in fraudulent or deceitful practices to avoid paying the debt by transferring the property to a third party.

6. Practical Consequences

• Protection for creditors: The section gives creditors assurance that the debtor cannot evade their legal obligation to repay debts by secretly transferring property out of their reach.
• Risk for the debtor: If a debtor tries to transfer or alienate attached property without the court's approval, they could face legal consequences and may be required to restore the property to the creditor or pay compensation.

Punishment

Punishment for Private Alienation: The alienation of attached property without the court's permission renders such transactions void, meaning the debtor’s actions will have no legal effect. However, there is no explicit criminal punishment defined under Section 64 itself. Instead, the consequences are more civil in nature, and the affected party (the creditor) can apply for legal remedies to:

• Restore the property back to its attached state.
• Seek damages for any harm caused by the invalid transaction.

Fraudulent Transfers: If it is found that the debtor has intentionally transferred the property to defraud the creditors, they could face serious consequences under the law, including potential charges of fraud, contempt of court, or misappropriation of assets, which could lead to penalties, fines, or imprisonment.

Enforcement of Rights: If the sale or transfer is found to be in violation of the section, the creditor has the right to request that the court declare the sale null and void, or to initiate further legal action to protect their interests.