Bailabel Type : non-bailable

Description

Order 31 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) deals with the legal provisions for suits by or against trustees, executors, and administrators. These individuals play key roles in managing the estates of deceased persons, trusts, or other fiduciary duties, and the order provides the framework for how these individuals can engage in litigation or be sued in court.

---

Key Provisions of Order 31

Rule 1: Suit by Trustees

1. Who Can File a Suit:

   • A trustee, who is appointed to manage the trust property, can file a suit in their capacity as the trustee of the trust. In this case, the suit must be filed in the name of the trustee, acting as the representative of the trust.
   • The trustee is responsible for representing the interests of the beneficiaries of the trust and is required to take legal action on behalf of the trust when needed.

2. Verification of Plaint:

   • A plaint filed by a trustee must be verified by the trustee as per the verification process outlined in the CPC. This includes a statement that the trustee is authorized to file the suit on behalf of the trust.
   • The verification should confirm that the information provided in the plaint is true to the best of the trustee’s knowledge and belief.

Rule 2: Suit Against Trustees

1. How to Sue a Trustee:

   • When a suit is filed against a trustee, the trustee is sued in their capacity as the representative of the trust. However, the trustee is personally responsible for legal obligations arising from their actions as a trustee. In cases of negligence or breach of trust, the trustee may be personally liable.
   • The summons and all legal notices are served on the trustee acting on behalf of the trust. If the trustee is sued in their personal capacity, they must defend themselves in the court.

2. Service of Summons:

   • The suit is generally filed against the trustee by name, with a request to act in their official capacity as the representative of the trust. The summons should be served on the trustee at their registered address or the trust’s registered office, depending on the legal arrangement.

3. Trustee’s Personal Liability:

   • In cases where the trustee’s personal actions or negligence have caused harm or loss to the trust or its beneficiaries, the trustee may be personally liable for the damages or claims. For example, if a trustee is accused of mismanaging the trust's assets, the court may hold the trustee personally accountable.

Rule 3: Suit by Executors or Administrators

1. Who Can File the Suit:
   • Executors or administrators are appointed to manage the estate of a deceased person. They can file suits on behalf of the estate or defend claims against the estate in their official capacity.
   • An executor is usually appointed through a will, while an administrator is appointed when there is no will or in cases where the executor is unable to act.
2. Verification of Plaint:
   • A plaint filed by an executor or administrator must be verified by the executor or administrator themselves. They must affirm that the contents of the plaint are true, and they are acting in their official capacity to manage the estate’s interests.

Rule 4: Suit Against Executors or Administrators

1. How to Sue Executors or Administrators:
   • When an executor or administrator is sued, the suit must be filed against them in their capacity as the representative of the deceased’s estate. They may be held liable if they fail in their duties to administer the estate properly or breach any fiduciary duties.
2. Personal Liability:
   • Executors and administrators are typically not personally liable for the estate’s debts unless they act outside the scope of their duties or negligently manage the estate’s assets. However, if they misuse or mismanage the estate, they could be held personally liable.
3. Service of Summons:
   • The summons for a suit against an executor or administrator is served on the executor/administrator personally, not the estate. The individual is required to represent the estate in court.
   • The summons is typically served at the executor’s or administrator's registered address.

Rule 5: Power to Appoint Substitutes

1. Delegation of Powers:
   • A trustee, executor, or administrator has the ability to appoint a substitute to act on their behalf in legal matters concerning the trust or estate, provided the legal framework allows it. This appointment ensures that the estate or trust is continuously managed and represented in legal matters even if the primary individual is unavailable or unable to act.
2. Liability of Substitute:
   • The substitute who is appointed to act on behalf of the trustee, executor, or administrator is subject to the same legal responsibilities and liabilities as the original person. The substitute must carry out their duties in line with the fiduciary obligations of the trustee, executor, or administrator.

Punishment

1. Liability for Breach of Duty:

   • If a trustee, executor, or administrator fails to carry out their responsibilities properly or breaches their fiduciary duty, they may be personally liable for the consequences. In cases of negligence or fraud, they could be required to compensate the trust or estate for any financial losses incurred.

2. Dismissal of Suit:

   • If the trustee, executor, or administrator is not acting within their official capacity or does not have the necessary authorization to represent the trust or estate, the court may dismiss the suit.

3. Personal Liability for Wrongdoing:

   • In cases where a trustee, executor, or administrator is found to have misused their position or acted in bad faith, they may be ordered to pay damages or be removed from their position, potentially resulting in legal penalties and financial consequences.