Description

Order 44 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) governs appeals by indigent persons in civil cases. This provision is designed to ensure that a person who is unable to pay the court fees due to financial constraints is not denied access to justice. It allows indigent persons to file an appeal without having to pay the required court fees, thus removing the financial barrier to the appellate process.

Key Provisions of Order 44 CPC:

1. Rule 1 - Definition of an Indigent Person:

• An indigent person is defined as one who is unable to pay the prescribed court fees due to financial incapacity. This provision recognizes that justice should be accessible to all individuals, regardless of their economic status.

2. Rule 2 - Filing of Appeal by an Indigent Person:

• An indigent person can apply to the appellate court for permission to appeal without paying court fees.
• The person must file an application stating their inability to pay the court fees and providing evidence to support their claim of indigence.
• The application for leave to appeal must be filed along with the memorandum of appeal (the document outlining the grounds of appeal) and must indicate that the applicant cannot afford to pay the required court fees.

3. Rule 3 - Examination of the Application:

• The appellate court will examine the application for permission to appeal and assess whether the applicant qualifies as an indigent person.
• The court may require the applicant to provide proof of their financial status, such as income details, assets, liabilities, or any other relevant information.

4. Rule 4 - Rejection of Application:

• If the appellate court finds that the applicant is not genuinely indigent, it may reject the application and require the person to pay the prescribed court fees.
• The court will assess the economic condition of the person to ensure that only those truly unable to pay are granted permission to appeal as an indigent person.

5. Rule 5 - Procedure After Acceptance of Application:

• If the appellate court grants permission to appeal, the indigent person can proceed with the appeal without paying the court fees.
• The court will then proceed with the hearing of the appeal based on the merits of the case.

6. Rule 6 - Security for Costs:

• The appellate court may require the indigent appellant to provide security for the costs of the appeal. This could include providing a bond or other security to cover the legal costs in case the appeal is unsuccessful.

7. Rule 7 - Dismissal for Failure to Pay Costs:

• If the indigent person is granted permission to appeal but later fails to provide security for costs or fails to meet other court requirements, the appellate court may dismiss the appeal.

8. Rule 8 - Powers of the Appellate Court:

• If the court grants an indigent person permission to appeal, the appellate court has the same powers it would have in any other appeal, such as reviewing the case on its merits, passing interim orders, or staying the operation of the lower court's decree.
• The indigent person can proceed with the appeal without paying the court fees but will be treated the same as other appellants in terms of the proceedings and final decision.

---

Purpose of Order 44 CPC:

The primary goal of Order 44 is to ensure that individuals who lack the financial means to pay court fees are not denied access to justice. By allowing indigent persons to file an appeal without the need to pay fees, it safeguards the right to a fair trial and ensures that justice is not solely accessible to those with financial resources. This provision helps in promoting equality before the law and makes the judicial process more inclusive.

Punishment

Order 44 does not prescribe punishments per se but outlines consequences if the provisions are not adhered to:

1. Dismissal of the Appeal:

   • If the applicant is found not to be indigent or fails to provide sufficient proof of financial incapacity, the court may dismiss the application to appeal as an indigent person, and the appellant will then be required to pay the prescribed court fees.

2. Dismissal for Failure to Comply with Court Orders:

   • If an indigent person fails to provide security for costs or does not comply with the procedural requirements set by the court, the appellate court may dismiss the appeal or take appropriate action based on non-compliance.

3. False Claims of Indigence:

   • If it is discovered that the appellant falsely claimed indigence or concealed assets to avoid paying the court fees, this can result in the dismissal of the appeal. Additionally, the court may impose penalties or fines for misrepresentation or fraudulent claims.